Important Note

Tufts ended funding for its Open Courseware initiative in 2014. We are now planning to retire this site on June 30, 2018. Content will be available for Tufts contributors after that date. If you have any questions about this please write to edtech@tufts.edu.

Tufts OpenCourseware
Search
Author: Ming Y Chow

Tufts OpenCourseWare
Introduction to Game Development
M. Chow
Spring 2012

 

Game Design Principles

Motivation: Why Do We Love Pong?

  • Simple
  • Every game is unique
  • Elegant representation (of table tennis in real life)
  • Social: it takes two to play
  • Fun
  • Cool

What is a Game?

  • What are the differences between a movie and a game?
    • A movie does not require any input from a user; a game does
    • A movie has a predetermined ending; a game sometimes have no ending, sometimes have one ending, sometimes you can have multiple ways to die
    • You have to make (interesting) decisions. There are consequences for all decisions
  • What are the differences between a toy and a game?
    • Every game is unique; you face different choices in each game
    • A game has rules and clearly-defined goals
    • There may be constraints in a game
  • A game has a universe
    • Players
    • Objects (e.g., vehicles)
    • Terrains
    • Behaviors: e.g., physics, sound, speech, emotions
  • Pretending - the mental ability to establish a notion of reality

What is a Digital Game?

  • Immediate interactivity
  • Visible and measurable feedback
  • Narrow input and output
  • Information manipulation
  • Automation of complex systems (e.g., graphics, AI)
  • Network communications
  • Integration of all the traits above

What is Fun?

  • Games tap into human motivation systems
  • Fun = self determination theory

Game Design Principles

  • "Why should someone else play it?"
  • Identify the players and the audience
  • Identify the genre, which may automatically put in place constraints
  • Identify the universe and landscape
  • Identify the constraints and goals
    • Determine the criteria for success. How do you win? How do you lose?
  • Determine the rules of interaction
    • Controls; interaction with character, put the player in some environment
    • How do you explain constraints to the player? Do you tell a story?
  • Operational issues (e.g., delivery)

Rules

  • Semiotics - symbols; sometimes abstract and sometimes have parallels in the real world
  • Gameplay - the challenges that a player must face to arrive at the objective of the game; the actions that the player is permitted to take to address those challenges
  • Sequence of play - progression of activities
  • Goal(s) of the game - the objective of the game
  • Termination condition - a.k.a, victory conditions, a.k.a., end-game
  • Metarules - rules about the rules

Common Goals in Games

  • Beat the final boss
  • Save the princess
  • Capture the king, the country, flag, etc.
  • Save the world
  • Beat your opponent, the other guy
  • Get the highest score
  • Complete all the levels
  • Build the best {fill in the blanks} without going bankrupt
  • Sandboxing; play God (a.k.a., "wuss" mode)
  • Achieve something (e.g., reunite the Triforce)
  • Grab a lot of grub
  • Get the most kills
  • Kill everything that moves
  • Be the last man standing
  • Don't die
  • Beat the clock; don't run out of time
  • Character building
  • Build relationships
  • Solve a puzzle
  • Level up
  • Make the right choices (well, try not to screw up)

Designing the Gameplay: Making the Fun Happen

  • Some skill or strategy involved
  • Feeling of accomplishment
  • Immersion: you are living a different life, or something that you wish you were
  • Anticipation: do I look forward to playing this? Can this pass time? Sometimes addiction.
  • Replay value
  • A good story
  • Believable story
  • Good production
  • Real-world feel
  • Bug-free
  • At least give me a chance
  • Reasonable learning curve
  • Some variety
  • Not too linear
  • Game balance
  • Competition
  • Well, is it suitable for certain people?

Core Mechanics

  • Determines how the game actually operates
  • Consist of data and algorithms that precisely define the game's rules and internal operations
  • Should be so precisely stated that the programmers can write the code
  • Its functions:
    • Operate the internal economy of the game
    • Present active challenges
    • Accept player actions
    • Detect victory or loss
    • Operate the artificial intelligence
    • Switch the game from mode to mode
    • Transmit triggers to the storytelling engine

Designing Core Mechanics

  • Keep it simple and elegant
  • Look for patterns, then generalize
  • Don't strive for perfection (on paper)
  • Refinement is important

What are the rules and core mechanics of Monopoly?

Game Balance

  • Fairness (start symmetrical: equal resources and powers to all)
  • Asymmetrical
  • Challenges vs. success
  • Meaningful choices: low risk / low reward, high risk / high reward
  • Short vs. long
  • Rewards
  • Punishment

Feedback

  • What happens when you win?
  • What if you lose?

Uh oh.....Game Design and Gameplay Blunders

  • Very flat; linear gameplay
  • Incorrect facts
  • Really really poor production: bad acting, bad voiceover, bad translation, bad everything
  • Bad physics
  • The unfinished or rushed game. The consequences:
    • Overworked developers
    • Bad testing; bugs galore
    • Doesn't sell well
    • Players get pissed
    • Patch /update hell
  • I need the CD to play this game?
  • False promise (a.k.a., Duke Nukem Forever)
    • Not as good as advertised
    • WHAT? I HAVE TO PAY FOR THIS PLUGIN IN THE GAME?!?!?!?!
  • Dead as you know it
  • Unrealistic storyline
  • LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOONG movie that you CAN'T SKIP
  • Bad camera control
  • Bad AI
  • Repetition, no variety
  • You can't save
  • I don't know what to do; lack of feedback
  • Really really clunky user interface
  • Too much emphasis on sound, graphics
  • Really bad sequel
  • Really bad support
  • Poor lighting
  • Bad port
  • Poor performance; game crashes

Game Genres

  • Classifications of digital game features
  • Describe the style of the game
  • Problems:
    • Most games fit into multiple genres
    • The list of nomenclatures goes on forever (see below)
    • No standard; been an issue of controversy
  • Importance: Set expectations
    • For players: they know what to expect in the game
    • For developers: they have to adhere to the design patterns (sometimes known as the "unwritten rules") of the genre

The Running List of Popular Genre Nomenclatures

  • Strategy
  • First-Person Shooter (FPS)
  • Real-Time Strategy (RTS)
  • MMORPG
  • RPG
  • Adventure
  • Action
  • Simulation
  • Sports
    • Racing
  • Shoot 'Em Ups / Beat 'Em Ups / Blow 'Em Ups
  • Brawlers
  • Fighting
  • Sidescroller
  • Puzzle
  • Party
  • God Games
  • Music
  • Space Shooter
  • 2D Space
  • Movie-Based / Full-Motion Video
  • History
  • Education / Edutainment
  • Simulation
  • Stealth
  • Interactive Fiction
  • Text
  • ...and this list goes on!

Genre: 2D Space (a.k.a., Shoot 'Em Ups; Arcade)

  • Examples: Space Invaders, Asteroids, R-Type, Defender, Chromium
  • Spurred the arcade boom in the '80s
  • Easy to develop
  • Problems: unrewarding; stale; not a good sell anymore

Genre: Simulation

  • Examples: SimCity, any EA sport game
  • Mimics real-world scenarios, including physics, atmosphere, and limitations

Genre: Massively Multiplayer Online Role Playing Games (MMORPGs)

  • Examples: World of Warcraft, Everquest, City of Heroes, City of Villians
  • Descendant of interactive fiction and Multi-User Dungeons (MUDs) (e.g., Ultima)
  • Popularly subscription-based for revenue stream
  • Character-building
  • Requires computer networking
  • Problems: software patches; out-of-game economies; addiction; can have lots of mundane and boring tasks

Genre: Interactive Fiction (a.k.a., Adventure, Text-Based or Graphical)

  • Examples: Blade Runner, the book, Adventure, Zork
  • Sometimes known as interactive drama
  • Immersive story
  • Primarily text
  • Completeness of world
  • Prose
  • Challenges and puzzles are typically conceptual solved by lateral thinking
  • The world is essentially a (mathematical graph) where each node in the graph is a separate scene
    • Tree
    • Death trap (many ways to be dead)
    • Open world
  • You are faced with discrete and limited choices
  • You could be dead as you know it, or loop around the world with no end
  • What to avoid
    • Puzzles solvable only by trial-and-error
    • Illogical spaces. Perfect example: Legend of Zelda (NES), the second quest
    • Require outside knowledge

Elements of a Game Design Document

  • Game Title
  • Overview
  • Gameplay mode
  • Core features in the game
  • Secondary features in the game
  • State diagrams (schematics)
  • Internal economy
  • Game balance
  • Victory conditions
  • Interface design (high-tech or low-tech)

The Importance of a Game Design Document

  • Memory (i.e., Have a plan? Write it down!)
  • Communications
  • Identify system limitations
  • Scope tentative project plan and budget
  • Good read: The 7 Deadly Sins of Startup Companies